Practice02.09.268 min
A second weight is a decision someone will get wrong
On designing identity systems for people who will never read the guidelines, at three in the morning, in the rain.
Lê Minh Châu
- Identity
- Wayfinding
- Practice
Every identity system we have ever inherited has the same failure mode. Not the mark — the mark is usually fine. It is the seventh variant, added in year three by a supplier who needed something the guidelines did not cover and who made a reasonable decision in isolation.
The guidelines are not the system
A 90-page brand manual is a document about a system. The system itself is whatever is physically installed, printed and worn. Those diverge the moment the studio stops being in the room, and they diverge in proportion to how many choices the manual leaves open.
So we design down. Two type sizes instead of five. One weight instead of a family. Four colours with no tints. Every variable removed is a decision a contractor in 2034 cannot get wrong.
You are not designing for the pitch. You are designing for a night-shift supervisor with a vinyl cutter and half an hour.
What this costs
It costs range. A single-weight system cannot do everything a family can, and there are projects where that is the wrong trade. A publisher needs the range. A port does not.
It also costs us something in the pitch, because a constrained system looks thinner on a slide than a generous one. We have lost work over it. We have not yet lost a system.
The test
Before we sign off, we print the thing at the smallest size it will ever appear, photograph it in bad light, and hand it to someone who has not seen the project. If they can read it and reproduce it, it ships.